Cash Issues is a collaboration between NewMusicBox and I CARE IF YOU LISTEN, supported by New Music USA.
The classical music sphere is presently buzzing with discussions about getting ready artists for a extra “entrepreneurial” strategy—providing sensible coaching within the expertise essential to forge a sustainable profession. Nevertheless, amidst the webinars and conservatory programs geared toward fostering this entrepreneurial spirit, there stays a evident difficulty:
The pay is way too low.
As a singer-turned-entrepreneur who co-founded Victory Corridor Opera, and now teaches entrepreneurship on the College of Virginia, I resonate with Anna Wiener’s commentary in her New Yorker article from 2025. She factors out that an entrepreneurial mindset usually will get a lift throughout occasions of excessive unemployment, resulting in a paradoxical state of affairs the place “too many individuals are working excessively exhausting for insufficient rewards.”
Is that this newfound embrace of entrepreneurship in classical music an admission of defeat? Does it recommend that musicians ought to now not count on to earn a sustainable dwelling? As somebody who has navigated each the creative and administrative sides of the trade, I’ve insights to share.
Artist charges—particularly efficiency charges—have been constantly declining for many years. Whereas complete statistics are exhausting to search out, anecdotal proof from friends signifies that, adjusted for inflation, charges have dropped to a 3rd or much less of their earlier, already-meager ranges over the past 25 years.
Are youthful generations unwilling to make sacrifices for the la vie bohème, or is it untenable for them to be anticipated to lose cash by taking gigs? This concern was highlighted in composer Juhi Bansal’s 2022 essay, a catalyst for this “Cash Issues” collection. Initially, the narrative round declining charges pointed to financial downturns.
Significantly in opera, corporations started balancing their budgets by way of exploitative Younger Artist Applications—a subject I explored in a latest movie known as YAPs. Later, diminished viewers numbers have been blamed, adopted by the pandemic and shifting cultural consumption habits. The narrative appeared limitless.
Nevertheless, my experiences in administration reveal that prioritizing honest compensation for artists shouldn’t be as difficult because it appears. Within the chaos of artist-centric mission statements and working ideas, it has turn into straightforward to make cuts. Many organizations lack the “political will” to alter this. Whereas their mission statements usually emphasize viewers engagement and neighborhood focus, few prioritize the artists themselves.
Russell Willis Taylor, former CEO of the English Nationwide Opera, insightfully said that for artist charges to return to livable ranges, arts organizations should reassess their fastened and variable prices. If fastened prices characterize workplace hire, workers salaries, and manufacturing budgets, the variable prices then turn into the charges paid to artists. Many organizations depend on the belief that there’ll at all times be extra determined, youthful entrants keen to simply accept much less.
But, classical music can’t thrive solely on the efforts of hobbyists and younger expertise. We’d like skilled artists to hone their craft and impart their knowledge to the subsequent technology, guaranteeing the continuity of this wealthy artwork type. Center-aged professionals naturally count on to earn an honest dwelling; thus, why would organizations spend money on seasoned artists after they can discover youthful, inexpensive replacements?
By adopting what I name the Russell Willis Taylor Precept, arts organizations might ask themselves: What if artists have been thought-about the fastened prices as an alternative? In that case, they may afford to pay honest compensation by lowering bills in different areas, equivalent to workplace hire, workers salaries, or simplifying manufacturing setups. It finally boils all the way down to will and intentionality.
The saying goes, “Present me your price range, and I’ll reveal your values.” Once we based Victory Corridor Opera in 2015, we outlined six core Founding Rules. Over the previous ten seasons, we now have examined these beliefs towards the realities of opera manufacturing, and Precept #5 stays essential:
5. Skilled Respect
Victory Corridor Opera shall keep an angle of respect for the skilled and creative standing, integrity, potential, and accomplishments of artists. We are going to prioritize the honest compensation of those artists above different manufacturing and administrative prices.
It could actually be that straightforward.
However how can organizations outline their true “values”? Somewhat reflection and energy can go a great distance. Listed here are a number of steps any arts group can take to align their budgeting with creative values:
- Establish the distinctive worth proposition of your work, and
- Acknowledge who generates that worth.
- Put money into them by establishing this as written coverage and ideas that
- Direct your group’s monetary and different decisions.
Nevertheless, the onus shouldn’t be solely on establishments; artists and their brokers should additionally construct the braveness and expertise wanted to advocate for his or her financial well being by negotiating higher contracts. Whereas this will appear daunting amid the pressures of provide and demand, let’s do not forget that classical music exists largely in a heavily-supported nonprofit surroundings, not within the cutthroat world of company capitalism. If we’re the worth, we should begin appearing prefer it.
As artists, I perceive that it may be difficult to advocate for oneself. In contrast to conventional enterprise faculties, conservatories hardly ever supply negotiation coaching. However maybe that is exactly the place these entrepreneurship packages can empower us, as efficient negotiation is a ability that may be discovered. When provided a gig, it’s pure to really feel excited and anxious to simply accept instantly. This urgency could make negotiating really feel significantly daunting.
To arrange for these moments, it’s important to ascertain private pointers and be taught efficient negotiation methods. I enhanced my expertise by way of a course at Stanford led by famend negotiator Margaret Neale, because of a scholarship from The Music Academy of the West. I extremely suggest her e-book, Getting (Extra of) What You Need.
Listed here are some methods I’ve discovered which have positively impacted my funds (and self-respect):
- Set the “anchor” by stating your required payment first. Don’t hesitate to begin on the upper finish; that’s the essence of negotiation.
- Dispel the worry that stating your payment will end in dropping the gig. The probability of rejection is commonly overstated.
- Know your backside line and don’t settle for something under it. Decide what compensation would make you’re feeling revered on your experience and energy.
- Bear in mind: You’re the worth. As an expert artist, you’ve honed a uncommon ability set; you aren’t interchangeable, and you’re the resolution to the employer’s want.
- The whole lot is negotiable. Don’t hesitate to ask for union-recommended rehearsal hours or further help to satisfy your position.
Don’t let the worry of being branded as “troublesome” or dropping alternatives deter you from advocating on your wants. Proof exhibits that employers usually worth you extra for standing agency in negotiations.
Right now, the classical music trade promotes artist-entrepreneurship as a mutually helpful association—empowering artists, fostering innovation, and including variety—whereas failing to carry establishments accountable for actual change.
What these organizations usually overlook is that prioritizing honest pay isn’t simply good ethics; it’s helpful for sustainability. Honest compensation results in longer, extra fulfilling careers, enhanced artist well-being and loyalty, elevated entry to creative contributions, and finally elevates the general high quality and influence of the artwork produced. Clearly, funding within the artwork type means investing in its artists.
Think about this analogy: I don’t query my plumber when he identifies that my corroded pipes want changing; I belief his experience and gladly pay the invoice, recognizing its necessity for the maintenance of my dwelling.
———————————————–
For extra insights on artist-centered insurance policies and advocacy, take a look at this Coverage Report produced by SINGTANK, an artist-advocacy assume tank I co-directed by way of 2021-2025.
I CARE IF YOU LISTEN operates as an editorially impartial program below the American Composers Discussion board and depends on beneficiant help from donors and establishments. You may help ICIYL’s mission with a tax-deductible contribution to ACF. For extra data, go to composersforum.org.
